| 1980 SEASON |
|---|
| South Atlantic League, Most Valuable Player |
| 1981 SEASON |
|---|
| Southern League All-Star Team, Outfield Topps Class AA All-Star Team, Outfield Yankees' Minor League Player Of The Year |
| 1982 SEASON |
|---|
| International League All-Star Team, Outfield Yankees's Magazine "82 for '82: The Faces to Watch This Season", #61 |
| 1983 SEASON |
|---|
| James P. Dawson Award, Outstanding Rookie At Yankees' Spring Training Yankees's Magazine "83 for '83: The Faces to Watch This Season", #71 |
| 1984 SEASON |
|---|
| American League All-Star Team The Sporting News American League All-Star Team The Sporting News American League Player of the Year |
| 1985 SEASON |
|---|
| American League All-Star Team American League Most Valuable Player, BBWAA American League Player of the Month -- August American League Player of the Month -- September American League Player of the Week -- August 5-11 American League Player of the Year Award, New York Chapter BBWAA Associated Press All-Star Team Baseball Bulletin All Star, First Base Baseball Bulletin Player Of The Year Mercedes Benz/Yankees Magazine Player of the Month -- July Mercedes Benz/Yankees Magazine Player of the Month -- August Mercedes Benz/Yankees Magazine Player of the Month -- September New York Daily News Player of the Month -- July New York Daily News Player of the Month -- August New York Daily News Player of the Month -- September Rawlings American League Gold Glove Award, First Basemen Seagrams 7-Crown of Sports All-Star Team SportsChannel Most Valuable Player The Sporting News American League All-Star Fielding Team The Sporting News American League All-Star Team The Sporting News American League Player of the Year The Sporting News Major League Player of the Year The Sporting News Silver Slugger Team United Press International All-Star Team Yankees Magazine Most Popular Yankee |
| 1986 SEASON |
|---|
| American League All-Star Team American League Player of the Month -- September American League Player of the Year Award, New York Chapter BBWAA Associated Press All-Star Team New York Daily News Player Of The Month -- May Rawlings American League Gold Glove Award, First Basemen The Sporting News American League All-Star Fielding Team The Sporting News American League All-Star Team The Sporting News American League Player of the Year The Sporting News Silver Slugger Team United Press International All-Star Team |
| 1987 SEASON |
|---|
| American League All-Star Starting Team American League Player of the Month -- July American League Player of the Week -- July 6-12 American League Player of the Week -- July 13-19 Associated Press All-Star Team Rawlings American League Gold Glove Award, First Basemen The Sporting News American League All-Star Fielding Team The Sporting News American League All-Star Team The Sporting News Silver Slugger Team United Press International All-Star Team |
| 1988 SEASON |
|---|
| American League All-Star Team American League Player of the Week -- July 11-17 Rawlings American League Gold Glove Award, First Basemen The Sporting News American League All-Star Fielding Team |
| 1989 SEASON |
|---|
| American League All-Star Team New York Daily News New York Yankee Of The Month -- June Rawlings American League Gold Glove Award, First Basemen The Sporting News American League All-Star Fielding Team |
| 1990 SEASON |
|---|
| 1991 SEASON |
|---|
| Rawlings American League Gold Glove Award, First Basemen |
| 1992 SEASON |
|---|
| Rawlings American League Gold Glove Award, First Basemen |
| 1993 SEASON |
|---|
| American League Player Of The Week -- July 12-18 BBWAA Joan Payson Humanitarian Services Award Rawlings American League Gold Glove Award, First Basemen |
| 1994 SEASON |
|---|
| Rawlings American League Gold Glove Award, First Basemen |
| 1995 SEASON |
|---|
| Modell's Sporting Goods Yankees' Defensive Player Of The Month -- July |
| 1996 |
|---|
| 1997 |
|---|
| Children's Health Fund Lifetime Achievement Award -- January 27, 1997 |
| 1998 |
|---|
| Coca Cola Bottling: Sports Personality Of The Year The Sporting News: Yankee Player Of The 1980s |
| 1999 |
|---|
| New York Daily News: Team of the Century, First-Base (Runner-Up) |
| 2000 |
|---|
| 2001 |
|---|
| 2002 |
|---|
| Yankees Magazine Top 10 Mashers in Yankee History -- #10 |
1997-2002, Joseph Riccitelli, Jr.